Robin Naughton writes: “’Document everything, and I mean everything!’ is the advice constantly given to tenure-track faculty. Tenure-track faculty librarians are no exception to this mantra. That advice rarely comes with a how-to guide or any meaningful suggestion on how to do it. This article is an attempt, based on my experience, to provide an approach that can help academic librarians on the tenure track implement that advice by creating a tenure tracker and folder structure that are simple and easy to use.”