Dave Shumaker writes: “At a recent professional meeting, I was dismayed to find myself witnessing yet another discussion on whether those present should call themselves ‘librarians.’ The program that hosted this discussion opened with the observation that library spaces are shrinking in the postpandemic world and the question of whether the participants might stop calling themselves librarians if they no longer work ‘in a [physical] library.’ Everything I heard was a repetition of arguments I’ve heard over and over in the almost 50 years since I was working on my first professional degree.”