Tom Huddleston Jr. writes: “One morning in December 2004, four men in gray wigs and fake beards embarked on a daring heist. Their target: several volumes of some of the world’s rarest books, later valued at more than $5.7 million in total, located in the special collections library at Transylvania University in Lexington, Kentucky. Almost two months later, police arrested the almost-perpetrators of a multimillion-dollar art heist—not hardened criminals, it turned out, but four local college students.”